Baron'S Cove, Sag Harbor - Reviews, Rooms Options & Prices 2025

Book with us

Up to 10% cheaper

than on Booking.com

Key details

About the Resort

31 W. Water Street, Sag Harbor, New York, United States, 11963

Baron's Cove, a 4-star Sag Harbor hotel, blends nautical charm with modern amenities. The resort features a seasonal saltwater pool, complimentary bicycles, and a well-regarded restaurant known for sourcing local ingredients.

Rooms & Amenities

Guest rooms at Baron’s Cove include options with one king bed or two double beds, some featuring a private garden seating area. Each room offers modern amenities and light-filled spaces, ensuring a comfortable stay.

Dining Options

The Restaurant at Baron's Cove serves elevated Long Island cuisine for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, featuring local vegetables and sustainably sourced seafood. The lounge provides a relaxed environment with live music and a varied cocktail list.

Leisure & Activities

Baron’s Cove offers a variety of leisure activities, including complimentary bicycles and seasonal kayaking. Guests can also enjoy the fitness center, tennis court, and saltwater pool for recreation and relaxation.

Services & Local Area

Services at Baron’s Cove include daily housekeeping and concierge assistance to personalize guest experiences. The hotel is dog-friendly with designated pet-friendly rooms and provides complimentary shuttle service to local beaches.

View all

Select your room type

The hotel offers a variety of rooms including double rooms, family rooms, and suites with breakfast, free cancelations, and special deals

Village Double Room

Max:

2 persons

26 m²

Bed options:

2 Double beds

room details

Check Prices

Garden Double Room

Max:

2 persons

26 m²

Bed options:

2 Double beds

Shower

room details

Check Prices

Harbor Two Queen Rooms

Max:

2 persons

33 m²

Bed options:

2 King Size Beds

Bathtub

room details

Check Prices

Show all roomsLess

Price and Room Availability Calendar

Check availability and prices for your dates now!

Getting around

Explore available ways to reach your dream destination

City Centre

Sag Harbor800 m

Airports

Long Island MacArthur (ISP) 81.1 km

Republic (FRG) 109.6 km

Train

Southampton 14.0 km

Facilities

The hotel offers amenities for your comfortable stay and unforgettable experiences

Helicopter View Dining

“The onsite restaurant at Baron's Cove offers a dining experience that I still dream about. I indulged in a scallop dish that was absolute heaven and remains a weekly craving. My dining partner opted for a steak, also impressively delicious. The beautiful outdoor seating area during sunset made each meal even more special.” view full review

Stylish and Cozy Rooms

“My stay in a beautifully decorated harbor-view room was nice. The spacious room featured a full outdoor seating area overlooking the harbor, which was perfect for sipping on warm beverages as I enjoyed the sunset wrapped in a cozy blanket. It was immaculate and well-appointed, making it my personal oasis.” view full review

Relaxing Poolside Retreat

“The pool area at Baron's Cove is a true retreat. I loved how it was surrounded by striped cabanas, creating a relaxed atmosphere. The attentive staff promptly provided towels and refreshments, allowing me to soak in the sun and unwind after a busy day. It truly added to my overall experience.” view full review

Cozy Bar Environment

“The bar area at Baron's Cove is inviting and cozy, especially with its roaring fire adding a touch of warmth. I enjoyed sitting by the fire with a drink while relishing in the vibrant atmosphere. It was the perfect spot to unwind after a day of exploring the area.” view full review

General

No smoking on site
Wi-Fi
Free parking
Off-site car park
Safe deposit box
24-hour reception
VIP check-in/ -out
Express check-in/ -out
No pets allowed
Rooms/ Facilities for disabled
24-hour security
Luggage storage
Allergy-free rooms
Lift
ATM/Cash machine
Coffee shop
Fireplace
Smoke detectors
Electric vehicle charging station
Fire extinguishers
Key card access
Key access

Sports & Fitness

Fitness centre
Canoeing
Cycling
Tennis court
Yoga class
Aerobics
Fishing

Services

Free shuttle service
Valet parking
Pet amenities available
Room service
Housekeeping
Laundry
Dry cleaning
Tours/Ticket assistance
Welcome drink
Happy hour

Dining

In-room breakfast
Restaurant
Snack bar
Bar/ Lounge area
Packed lunches
Special diet menus

Business

Business centre
Meeting/ Banquet facilities
Fax/Photocopying

Children

Cots
Babysitting/Child services
Board games
Children's menu
Game room

Spa & Leisure

Seasonal outdoor pool
Beach access
Beach umbrellas
Live entertainment
Sun terrace
Garden area
Leisure/ TV room
Spa centre
Massage

Room features

Air conditioning
Heating
Soundproofed rooms
Terrace
Garden furniture
Trouser press

Location

31 W. Water Street, Sag Harbor, New York, United States, 11963

Map view

31 W. Water Street, Sag Harbor, New York, United States, 11963

City landmarks

Church

First Presbyterian Old Whalers Church

660 m

Harbour

Sag Harbor

1.2 km

Park

Sag Harbor Marine Park

1.2 km

114 Division St

Sage Street Antiques

650 m

Mashashimuet Park

1.3 km

Gallery

Monika Olko Gallery

1.2 km

Beach

Haven's Beach

2.3 km

Elizabeth A. Morton National Wildlife Refuge

3.4 km

Beach

Foster Memorial Town Beach

4.0 km

Barcelona Neck Road

Sag Harbor Golf Course

3.3 km

335 Ferry Rd

North Haven Village Park

3.5 km

1061 Bridgehampton-Sag Harbor Turnpike

Long Pond Greenbelt Nature Center

3.7 km

Lake

Trout Pond Park

4.2 km

376 Bridgehampton/Sag Harbor Tpke

Children's Museum of The East End

4.8 km

554 NY-114

Northwest Woods Trails

4.9 km

Museum

South Fork Natural History Museum and Nature Center

5.8 km

Nearby

Museum

Sag Harbor Whaling and Historical Museum

50 m

Main and Garden Street

Custom House Museum

50 m

8 Wharf St

The Windmill

50 m

Gallery

Grenning Gallery

50 m

Gallery

Romany Kramoris Gallery

50 m

Gallery

Tulla Booth Gallery

50 m

Restaurants

Baron's Cove

40 m

31 West Water Street

LT Burger

540 m

62 Main Street

Lulu Kitchen & Bar

540 m

126 Main St

Tutto il Giorno

540 m

16 Main Street

SagTown Coffee

620 m

78 Main St Suites 4 &5

Il Capuccino Ristorante

590 m

30 Madison St

Wolffer Kitchen Sag Harbor

560 m

29 Main St

Sen

520 m

23 Main St

Sag Pizza

560 m

103 Main Street

Corner Bar

500 m

1 Main St

La Super Rica

500 m

1 Main Street

Reviews and Ratings

Feedback from previous guests about their experience

72%

liked the resort and would come back again

7.2/10

Very good

Rooms

6.8

Location

9.3

Service

6.5

Dining

8.5

4/5 based on 339 reviews

#1 of 5 hotels in Sag Harbor based on Tripadvisor

Charles

United States, January 2025

8.4/10

We had a fantastic time at Baron's Cove. The atmosphere was so relaxing, the views were breathtaking, and the pool was a perfect escape from the heat. However, the dining prices were quite high, which made it hard to justify eating there beyond breakfast. Overall, it's a beautiful place but might require a deeper pocket for meals.

Rooms

9.0

The rooms were beautiful and incredibly comfortable, perfect for unwinding after a long day. I especially loved the patio area where we could enjoy the fresh air at night.

Service

7.0

While the staff were kind and helpful for the most part, I felt that some more training could improve the efficiency in acknowledging guests, especially during busy breakfast times.

Location

10.0

Baron's Cove is in a stunning location, situated right on the water and within walking distance to the charming town of Sag Harbor. We had a great time kayaking just across the street!

Dining

7.0

The food in the restaurant for breakfast was tasty, but the prices for other meals were pretty steep, which limited our dining experiences.

Facilities

9.0

The facilities, especially the pool area, were well-maintained and offered a perfect way to cool down during hot days.

Herbert

United States, December 2024

6.0/10

I had a mix of experiences at this hotel. On one hand, the dining was exceptional with a talented chef making our dinner memorable. However, the overall service during my stay was quite lacking, and the room was a major letdown given the price I paid. While the hotel's location is great, I can’t say it was worth what I spent.

Rooms

5.0

The room was quite disappointing—musty, small, and poorly maintained. I had expected a more luxurious experience for the money I paid.

Service

5.0

While some staff members were friendly, the service overall was unresponsive and did not meet my expectations, especially for a hotel charging premium rates.

Location

8.0

The hotel is conveniently located close to the town and within walking distance to shops and restaurants, which is a big plus.

Dining

9.0

Dinner was outstanding—the Lobster Roll and Ravioli were highlights, and the service in the dining area was much better than elsewhere in the hotel.

Facilities

6.0

The hotel appeared to have some nice amenities, but I found the pool area and common facilities to be average and in need of an upgrade.

John

United States, November 2024

7.8/10

I thoroughly enjoyed my stay at Baron's Cove, which offers a lovely blend of privacy and easy access to town, though it can get a bit pricey during peak times. The staff truly made the experience memorable with their attentiveness, but I did encounter some issues with the service regarding booking adjustments. Overall, it’s a charming spot with beautiful pool-facing rooms that are worth considering.

Rooms

7.0

The room we stayed in was stylish and flooded with light. The views were fantastic, but I found the vent to be noisy, which disrupted my sleep.

Service

6.0

While some staff members were incredibly helpful, I felt that the overall service could use some improvement in how they handle guest requests, especially in challenging situations.

Location

9.0

The location is fantastic—it’s a short walk to the marina and the village, yet feels private and cozy. It's right near the water, making for beautiful views.

Dining

8.0

The restaurant setting is beautiful and the food was excellent, but I thought breakfast service could be more attentive.

Facilities

9.0

The pool area was inviting and well-maintained, making it a great place to relax after exploring.

Will

United States, October 2024

5.2/10

Rooms

Service

Location

Dining

Facilities

Jill

United States, October 2024

9.2/10

Our stay at Baron's Cove was a memorable one, starting with the warm welcome we received upon arrival. The room was spacious and featured stunning views of the water, adding to the overall experience. However, while the amenities like the tennis court and pool were enjoyable, the overall price felt a bit high for what we received. Still, I'd recommend it for its charm and those breathtaking views.

Rooms

8.0

The room was spacious, clean, and offered beautiful views of the boats on the water. However, the air conditioning vent was a bit loud, making it difficult to sleep comfortably at times.

Service

9.0

The service was exceptional, with staff going out of their way to assist us, like delivering ice right to our room. It really added a personal touch to our stay.

Location

10.0

Being right on the water and just a short walk from Main Street made the location perfect for exploring Sag Harbor. We loved how convenient it was for dining and shopping.

Dining

10.0

Dining at the hotel's restaurant was a highlight, with delicious food and a lovely atmosphere enhanced by live music. I highly recommend requesting a balcony seat for a fantastic view.

Facilities

9.0

The hotel had great facilities, including a beautiful pool and well-maintained tennis courts. They really catered to guests looking for activities.